The book I chose to read is "Reading
Essentials: The Specifics You Need to Teach Reading Well" by Regie
Routman. I picked this book because most of its reviews are saying this book is
full of practical strategies and immediately doable tips on how to teach
reading well to students. I am now 50 pages into the book and I have to agree
that this book is really down-to-earth and highly practical. Even though a lot
of the content sounds like professional common sense, it still challenges
teachers to reflect on their own teaching and inspires them to do better.
The
core question this book attempts to answer is: what does it mean to be an
effective teacher of reading? However, Routman does not give us the right or
best answer to that question because there is No One" right" or best
way. Throughout the text, she gives her
informed opinion, but it is up to us, the reader, to decide what work for us
and our students in our particular school and classroom.
In
my first 50 pages of reading, a couple of Routman's ideas stood out. The first idea is bonding
with students. We have been told as teachers that we must love each of our
students. However, we have all had students who, for whatever reasons, are
difficult for us to love. But bonding is quite another matter. Bonding could be
as simple as looking at a student in the eye with interest or listening to what
a student has to say. Routman argues that if there is no bonding between
teachers and students, there will be no learning to occur. Once our students
bond with us and trust us, anything is possible. As a community college
instructor, I have heard my students talking about how they prefer our
classrooms to a large four-year university classroom. A major reason is that at
a community college, instructors get to know them individually as a person and
it is more likely to establish that personal connection between teacher and
student. I feel inspired by Routman's bonding idea because at the college-level
teaching, we seem to have overlooked the human and emotional aspect of
learning. We only get to meet our students once or twice a week, we assume that
our students are all adults and can take care of themselves, and we suppose
that as long as we teach them the content subject, we complete our job. Little
did I realize how much more effective learning would be if we bond with our
adult students.
Another
good idea that Routman proposes is maintaining a reading record for ourselves.
There are multiple benefits to keeping a reading record. It encourages us to
read more; it keeps track of our own reading; more importantly, teachers can
carry this habit over to students and help students become better readers. Routman
emphasizes that we teachers have to be readers if we are to teach reading and
writing well. That makes me feel ashamed of myself because I have never been a
big reader and I AM a reading teacher now. I want to change and I think keeping
a reading record can help me achieve my goal.
Hi! I chose the same book, and I think it will be interesting to hear what you think the important parts of the book are and you're interpretations and opinions. We could discuss it like a book club almost. :)
ReplyDeleteI agree with your point about the bonding. I wrote about that in my first chapter overview as well. I think it is very important to create the type of environment where there is mutual respect and the students want to be in your class. I agree with Routman that it is the foundation for a constructive learning environment. It was interesting to read about your connection to the small collage classroom. That sounds like a great way to see this through secondary+ education.
Hello! So glad two people are reading the same book which makes for interesting blogs to comment on from two perspectives. Nice. I will definitely tune into your blogs and Deanna's.
ReplyDeleteMy students at Dine College have also commented that surviving a community college is easier than a large 4 year university due to the individual attention each recieves from instructors. Some have even gone on to 4 year institutions and graduated with a BA degree. Bonding is essential in any classroom.
Hi Fang,
ReplyDeleteIt looks interesting textbook. I like those types of books that offers different strategies & practices. They help teachers, particulary new teachers to better work in the classroom. I like how you define "Bonding" as to look at a student in the eye with interest or listening to what a student has to say. I will be a follower here to enjoy more.
I totally agree with the bonding with the students being a benefit to learning. I never actually thought about ti but thinking back to my days at a community college and my days at UNM I do find that I got a lot more out of my community college classes because the teachers bonded with the students more. We were not just a number to them.
ReplyDeleteHi Fang, I'm only now getting to go back and read through some of your entries. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the really practical pieces. What do you think four year universities could learn from community colleges to help students feel more bonded and lead to more success?
ReplyDeleteAlso, I think the idea of keeping a reading record is really important. How often do we require this of our students, but not of our selves? I love that thinking about this has pushed you to be reflective on your own reading practices.
I know what you are saying about loving all of our students. I have been in that place...at all of the levels I teach at, where there is that ONE student who just doesn't connect with you. That one that won't make eye contact, interacts little to non, and expresses no emotion. It's a challenge, but it's a necessary one. Each student must feel a connection to their teacher. It's part of an honest dialogue in the community.
ReplyDelete